Do They Understand “No”?
April 2007
2 CommentsWhen this post was written: First child (D) was 3 yrs, 10 mo. Second child (B) was 2 yrs, 3 mo. Third child (L) was 0 yrs, 5 mo.
Do they understand “no”? Of course they do! However, I’ve noticed far quicker obedience when I am more specific about what I’m saying no about, particularly when it’s something the child doesn’t exactly know is unacceptable.
Last night, for example, Bethel (28 months) was pushing a very large model airplane that I had brought in from the garage and placed on the counter. I had a brief fear of the airplane careering off the counter and quickly said, “No.” Bethel looked up, and then continued pushing the plane. Was she ignoring me? I then said in the same tone and intensity, “Hands off.” She immediately took her hands away.
So I started thinking back to similar incidents, and I realized that she responds much better to specific, short commands instead of a vague no. It’s entirely possible that she really doesn’t always know immediately what she’s doing wrong and it takes a bit longer to figure it out. Alternative commands I can think of: Give Mommy. Get down. No touch. [I like Hands off better, though, because the first word the child hears tells the young child where the problem is.] Feet still [in church].
What do you think? Am I simply succumbing to secular psychological fuzzy wuzzy feel-good techniques? Of course I’m not saying the word no is never appropriate. I am just comparing the brain processing time of no versus a command like hands off.
Similar Posts:
Popularity: 3% [?]
Filed under: Communication and Meaning, Obedience
Subscribe to the 
Leave a 
…
I’m with you, Michelle. I think a child can be legitimately confused about what he’s doing that you’re telling him not to do.
My husband and I think every parent should read the Ramona books to help them remember what it’s like to be a kid and to be misunderstood or to be misunderstanding.
1 Addy said this (April 18, 2007 at 3:10 pm)
That does it. Addy, you may be entirely responsible for another Amazon run. It’s been a long time since I’ve read the Ramona books, and I bet Lee would enjoy them, too.
2 Michelle said this (April 18, 2007 at 3:47 pm)